11 Cookie of the Month Clubs That Make a Sweet Gift
Updated: Sep. 26, 2023
The best mail day? When the box from your cookie of the month club arrives! Find our top picks for decorated cookies, seasonal cookies and even cookie dough.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.
According to baking lore, cookies were an accident. They were test cakes put in the oven to assess the temperature. We’re glad they rose (no pun intended!) to fame the way they did because we can’t think of an occasion that isn’t made better with a cookie. A bad day? A great one? A memorable event? A quiet night? Pass the cookies.
Cookie-of-the-month clubs take things to another level. You’ll eagerly await the mail person’s arrival with one of these subscriptions, which include cozy classics and creative takes from the country’s best bakeries. You’ll get to enjoy cookies with a cult following or specially paired with the perfect cup of coffee.
One of our favorite things about these clubs? They make the perfect gift for birthdays, holidays or even just because. They’ll delight foodies, sweet tooths and people who seem to have everything. Trust us—you can never have too many cookies.
Treating someone to monthly boxes full of fresh-baked gourmet cookies is our favorite way to brighten the day. Psst! Don’t forget to snag yourself a subscription too.
David’s Cookie-of-the-Month Club
If you’re craving the cookies Grandma used to make, sign up for David’s Cookies monthly club. Orders from this cookie of the month club contain either a singular flavor or an assortment, with beloved varieties such as oatmeal raisin, butterscotch pecan and double chocolate chunk. Send a loved one (or yourself!) sweet joy for three, six, nine or 12 months.
Levain Cookie Club
If you’re on Instagram, you’ve probably seen Levain Bakery and its gigantic, extra-gooey cookies. As part of the cookie club, you’ll receive a bite of the good life each month (i.e., eight of the company’s famous cookies). Our favorite part: You get to try some new flavors before they’re shared with the public. Read exactly what we thought of these cookies in our review.
Feed Your Soul Cookie-of-the-Month Club
We love gifts that give back. And this cookie-of-the-month club from Feed Your Soul Bakery is no exception. For three, six or 12 months, you can indulge in a dozen fresh, flavorful cookies. Enjoy classics, such as snickerdoodle and chocolate chunk, and more unique varieties, such as lemon-berry and “Show Me the Honey.” Plus, every purchase provides meals (and cookies!) to those in need.
Little Red Kitchen Cookie of the Month
We can’t think of a sweeter surprise than the contents of this cookie box by Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop. Your subscription—available in three-, six- or 12-month increments—includes either one dozen cookies or an 8-inch cookie pie every month. Past flavors include lemon sugar, caramel apple oatmeal and the unforgettable Elvis cookie pie. For more of the finer things in life, see these cheese-of-the-month clubs.
Cheryl’s Buttercream Frosted Cut-Out Cookie Club
Who can say no to soft, buttercream-frosted cookies? Certainly not us! This pay-as-you-go frosted cookie subscription—available in both six- and 12-month lengths—is perfect for anyone who loves a classic treat. Each shipment includes two dozen cutouts in a variety of seasonal shapes. Discover more tasty food of the month clubs.
Goldbelly Monthly Cookie Subscription
What if you could try some of the best cookies in the country without having to travel and line up outside bakeries? This Goldbelly cookie subscription takes you on a sugary tour of some of the most beloved and imaginative cookies. Expect to be delighted and surprised, and to find some new obsessions along the way. Nibbles of chocolate chip cookies, whoopie pies and Hawaiian delicacies await.
Organic Coffee & Gourmet Cookie Club
In Germany, coffee with cake is a tradition, and it’s one we’d like to start practicing ASAP. This subscription box sends you two fresh-baked cookies and one 4-ounce bag of ground coffee for a cozy monthly treat. Each cookie-coffee combo is carefully selected based on flavor profiles. Add this to your list of coffee subscription boxes too!
Doughp Secret Cookie Dough Club
Grab a spoon! You’ll want to eat Doughp’s amazing (and safe!) cookie dough right out of the container. Choose to receive a two-pint delivery every month, then indulge in flavors like chocolate chip, sprinkles, frosting or chocolate brownie. No oven needed.
Baketini Cookie-of-the-Month Club
These cookies are almost too pretty to eat! Impeccably detailed treats, these hand-decorated cookies feature royal icing and cutout shapes. Plus, each box has a theme that matches the current season. Pick up a dozen cookies for one, three or six months.
Cheryl’s Flavor-of-the-Month Cookie Club
With this flavor-of-the-month cookie club, you’ll receive a new seasonal flavor, such as cinnamon pumpkin in October to go with your PSL or frosted lemon to usher in April. Each cookie comes individually wrapped. To bring more seasonal flair to your house, don’t forget a flower subscription.
French Macarons Box
Ooh la la! Crafted by French chefs in California, this macarons subscription box from Pastreez makes an elegant food gift. Each month includes a 12-pack of macarons in a variety of flavors—think salted caramel, mango, pumpkin and lots more. Subscribe for three, six or 12 months. It’s cheaper than a ticket to Paris!
Additional research contributed by Katie Bandurski, Taste of Home Senior Shopping Editor
