The word knish (pronounced kuh-nish) might not be in everyone’s vocabulary, but my mother has fond memories of this Jewish comfort food. On the weekends, she would go shopping with my grandmother on Jerome Avenue in the Bronx. After shopping for bagels and bialys, they would hit the deli for whitefish. From time to time, my grandmother would also pick up knish for lunch. Although most people describe these potato-filled dumplings as comfort food, my mother thought of them as a treat.
My father also remembers them fondly, but he enjoyed them for different reasons. In the winter, he would buy two knishes and stuff them in his pockets. The hot potato filling would radiate heat throughout his coat, keeping him warm until the knish finally cooled down. Then, they’d be lunch!
What Is a Knish?
It’s a soft, pillowy piece of dough, filled to the brim with seasoned mashed potatoes. Each piece is traditionally rolled into a round ball and baked, although they can be formed into squares and deep-fried for a crispy exterior.
When I asked my parents about their favorite flavors, my mother laughed. She only ever remembers one filled with potatoes, although my father supposes there might be all kinds today (after all, they put pineapple on pizza, so anything is possible). It turns out he’s right: Some knish contain meat, cheese, kasha (buckwheat groats) or onions, and today’s chefs are making all kinds of non-traditional knishes like wild mushroom or wasabi and potato with crystallized ginger.
A Brief History of Knishes
According to Laura Silver, author of Knish: In Search of the Jewish Soul Food, the knish originally comes from Eastern Europe. Jewish immigrants brought it to the United States in the early 1900s, and the knish made its first appearance on New York’s Lower East Side. Wherever Jews moved, knisheries were sure to open until they peppered the landscape of Brooklyn, the Bronx and Coney Island. Unfortunately, knishes never took off like other types of dumplings, and it’s hard to find them outside New York.
How to Make a Knish
This recipe was inspired by Ida Gardner, who learned it from her mother, a caterer in Baltimore known as the “Knish Lady.” The dough is relatively easy to pull together, although you could use frozen puff pastry as a shortcut.
Ingredients
DOUGH:
- 2-1/2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 teaspoon baking powder
- 1 teaspoon kosher salt
- 1/2 teaspoon sugar
- 1 egg
- 3/4 cup warm water
- 1/3 cup canola oil
- 1 egg yolk whisked with 1 tablespoon water (for the egg wash)
FILLING:
- 1-1/2 pounds russet potatoes, peeled and cut into 1-inch pieces
- Kosher salt and pepper, to taste
- 1 tablespoon canola oil
- 1 small yellow onion, small diced
Yield: This recipe makes about a dozen knishes.
Instructions
Step 1: Prepare the dough
Before you get started, preheat the oven to 400°F. The dough doesn’t need to rest, so making the knishes will happen pretty quickly.
In a large bowl, combine the flour, baking powder, salt and sugar. Make a well in the center of the dry ingredients and add the eggs, oil and warm water. Stir until the dough comes together, and knead it briefly with your hands. Form the dough into a large ball and divide it in half. Wrap the dough in plastic wrap to keep it from drying out while you prepare the filling.
Editor’s Tip: To prepare knish in advance, you can make the dough and filling two to three days ahead of time and assemble the knish just before baking.
Step 2: Prepare the filling
Place the potatoes in a large pot and cover them with an inch of cold water. Season the water with salt and bring the mixture to a boil. Cook until the potatoes are tender when pierced with a fork, about 10 to 15 minutes. Drain the potatoes and mash them using a food mill or potato ricer.
Meanwhile, heat the canola oil in a skillet over medium-high heat. Add the onions and cook until they’re tender, about 15 minutes. Mix the onions into the mashed potatoes and season with salt and pepper, to taste.
Editor’s Tip: To make a beefy filling, add a pound of cooked ground beef to the mashed potato mixture. You can also add cheese or cooked vegetables, like steamed broccoli, spinach or mushrooms.
Step 3: Make the knishes
Dust a work surface with a little flour. Working with one piece of dough at a time, roll the dough out into a large rectangle that’s about 10×15 inches and 1/8 inch thick. Leaving about 1/4 inch between the filling and the bottom of the rectangle, place half the mashed potato filling onto the dough and form it into a large log. Pull the bottom edge of the dough over the filling and roll, folding the ends in as you go. Finish with the roll’s seam at the bottom.
Using your hands, stretch and press the rolled dough so the filling is evenly distributed throughout the log. Cut the dough into six pieces. Twist and pinch in the sides of each piece to form a ball. Place the balls on a parchment-lined baking sheet and brush each knish with the egg wash.
Step 4: Bake to perfection
Lindsay Mattison for Taste of Home
Bake the knish for 40 to 45 minutes until they’re golden brown, turning the pan halfway through to ensure the knish bake evenly. Let them sit for at least 5 minutes before serving. The filling will be piping hot, so enjoy with care!
Editor’s Tip: If you have leftovers, freeze them in an airtight container.
Similar Dishes from Other Regions
Almost every food culture has dumplings like knish. For starters, there are several types of dumplings made from potatoes, like German Kartoffelknodel or Italian gnocchi. Unlike knish, these dumplings don’t involve dough wrappers, making them more closely related to American chicken and dumplings.
When considering stuffed dumplings, the Polish pierogi is probably closest relative to a knish because of its potato filling. You could also look to Russian pelmeni, which also use thick-skinned dough wrappers, but they’re traditionally filled with ground meat and served with sour cream.
Other cultures use thin-skinned wrappers, like Italian ravioli, Korean mandu or the many Chinese dumplings served during dim sum service. If you’re in the mood for a crispier experience, look to Cornish pasties, South American empanadas or triangular-shaped Indian samosas.
Next up: Learn how to make bourekas, Jewish cheese-stuffed pastries.
Find More Recipes for Jewish Comfort Food
Baked Balsamic ChickenThis roast chicken is a nice change of pace from the classic Passover brisket. The
balsamic vinegar adds a savory sweetness to the chicken and helps the skin reach a deep brown color, making it look as good as it tastes.
Matzo Ball SoupPassover Seder wouldn't be the same without matzo ball soup! To simplify your day-of prep, you can make the soup ahead of time and pre-mix, shape and store the matzo balls in the refrigerator. From there, heat up the soup and cook the matzo balls just before serving.
(
Psst: the secret to making
matzo balls as good as your bubbe's is a splash of seltzer water in the batter.)
Passover Brisket
It doesn't get more traditional than Passover brisket. Making a gigantic brisket might seem intimidating, but it's the easiest way to feed a large crowd. If you have time,
make the brisket a day or two ahead of time and let it cool completely in the refrigerator. Cold brisket is much easier to slice than hot brisket.
Get Recipe
Passover Rainbow CookiesThese gorgeous layered cookies are made with almond flour and matzo meal, so they adhere to the
kosher for Passover rules. Feel free to change up the color of each layer by using different types of food coloring.
Gefilte Fish
Translated from Yiddish, gefilte fish means "stuffed fish." While recipes vary, it's generally made with a combination of fatty fish, lean fish and vegetables, with matzo meal and egg as a binder. It's important to let the fish balls cool down after cooking them, as they're traditionally served cold. Try the gefilte fish with a dollop of
maror.
Get Recipe
Apple Cake for PassoverThis cake is made with potato starch and matzo cake meal instead of flour, so it's kosher for Passover. You should be able to find the finely ground matzo cake meal at the grocery store. If not, measure an extra 2 tablespoons of
matzo meal for every cup and pulse it in a food processor until it resembles all-purpose flour.
Roasted Chicken & Red PotatoesWe love a roasted chicken recipe that takes care of the vegetable side dish at the same time the main entree cooks! Using chicken quarters instead of a whole chicken means dark meat only, so make sure to cook the chicken until it reaches an internal temperature of 175°F.
Find more traditional recipes in these
Jewish cookbooks.
Orange-Spiced BrisketBrisket is a common centerpiece in Jewish holiday celebrations because it comes from the breast of the cow in the front section, adhering to
kosher cooking guidelines. We love the addition of orange juice and warming spices like cinnamon and cloves, giving the rich brisket a festive touch. Hungry for more? Try these delicious
Jewish desserts.
Passover RollsThis is one of those Passover recipes that can be used all week long, so don't be afraid make these matzo meal rolls a few times over the holiday. Serve them at dinner with a pat of butter (or
nondairy butter) or enjoy them as sandwich bread. They're particularly good for breakfast with cream cheese and lox.
Roasted RadishesRoasted radishes are great with any holiday dinner, but they pair especially well with brisket or roast
chicken for Passover. Instead of using the olive oil called for in the recipe, try swapping in
schmaltz for an extra flavor boost.
TzimmesThis Jewish stew is rich in color and flavor, and it's a classic accompaniment to Passover or Rosh Hashanah. Between the sweet potatoes, carrots, dried plums, orange juice, honey and brown sugar, this dish is sweet enough that you won't need to serve dessert (but that doesn't mean you can't!).
Roasted Herb & Lemon CauliflowerRoasted cauliflower is one of our favorite vegetable side dishes because it's easy to make and it can be seasoned in any way to complement your main dish. When using ground spices, remember to look for spices that are specifically certified kosher for Passover.
Pistachio Baked SalmonRoasting salmon for Passover dinner is a great way to lighten up the meal. The pistachio topping creates a crunchy exterior that tastes great and complements the salmon's soft, fatty texture.
Lemon Herb QuinoaLeavened grains (wheat, spelt, oats, barley and rye) are a no-go for Passover, but
quinoa is generally accepted for Seder dinner. Although it looks pretty similar to couscous, quinoa is a seed that's a member of the same family as chard and beets.
Mediterranean Rack of LambThe tradition of eating lamb on Passover ended in 70 CE with the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem, and some Jews don't find it appropriate to serve lamb for Passover dinner. Others deem it acceptable if the lamb is roasted in a pan with liquid. Depending on your family's customs and interpretations of the rules, this breadcrumb-free rack of lamb could be perfect as your dinner centerpiece.
Garlic and Artichoke Roasted PotatoesArtichokes come into season right around the start of Passover, and they make a wonderful accompaniment to your favorite Passover potato recipe. If you can't find fresh artichokes, don't worry; frozen artichoke hearts work just fine.
Ribbon Salad with Orange VinaigretteThis salad is elegant in its presentation but simple in flavor, featuring light and crisp vegetables dressed in a bright vinaigrette. Use a
vegetable peeler to transform the carrots, cucumber and zucchini into elegant ribbons that elevate this salad to a holiday-worthy side dish.
Savory Rubbed Roast ChickenWho needs a complicated brine or marinade recipe when
dry rubs work just as well? This paprika-based rub is smoky, savory and slightly spicy, infusing the chicken with a ton of flavor in as little as an hour. To increase the flavors, let the rub sit on the chicken for up to 12 hours before roasting.
Passover PopoversTraditional dinner rolls aren't allowed for Seder dinner—Passover recipes must use unleavened grains only—but you won't miss them if you make these matzo cake meal popovers. They puff up and become delightfully crispy as they bake, and all you need to make them is a muffin pan.
Sweet and Sour BrisketJewish brisket is deeply rich and savory, so we love lightening it up with this sweet and sour glaze. The ingredients combine with the brisket juices as it braises in the slow cooker, creating an incredible sauce. If you end up with too much sauce, thicken it with
matzo cake meal to make a savory gravy.
Double-Nut Stuffed FigsIt can be hard to find grain-free Passover recipes for dessert, so it's the perfect opportunity to keep things simple and feature fruit instead of cakes. We like using dried Calimyrna figs here because their large size makes them well-suited for stuffing with the cocoa and nut filling. These
Passover desserts will end your meal on a sweet note.
Roasted Carrots & FennelFennel makes a fantastic addition to Passover dinner because it pairs well with any of the popular main dishes, whether that's beef, chicken, salmon or lamb. The bulb's natural anise flavor softens and mellows as it cooks, taking on a sweet edge that pairs really well with roasted carrots.
Tangy Lamb TagineThis Moroccan-spiced lamb stew tastes great the day you make it, but the flavors meld together and improve with an overnight rest in the refrigerator. You can make this recipe in a
Dutch oven on the stovetop or in the slow cooker. Your choice!
Mediterranean Mashed PotatoesMost mashed potato recipes are rich with dairy, so they aren't the best choice for a meat-heavy Seder meal. In this recipe, we use olive oil and lemon juice instead. The oil and citrus dresses the starchy potatoes with the perfect amount of fat and acid to create a creamy consistency without the need for milk.
Lemony Parsley Baked CodFish is considered kosher if it has both fins and scales, making cod a great choice when looking for Passover recipes. Cod is a very lean fish, so it doesn't have a lot of fat to protect it from drying out if it overcooks. We like cooking it at a high temperature in this recipe to keep the fish juicy and moist.
Jeweled Endive SaladJewel-toned pomegranate seeds make this salad shine visually, but it's the combination of watercress and endive that make it a star. The
endives are crisp and bitter while the watercress brings a sharp peppery note, coming together to create a burst of flavor in every bite.
Herb-Roasted Salmon FilletsRoast salmon is simple to make, but these herb-topped fillets look elegant for a holiday dinner. The fish cooks quickly in a high-temperature oven, so you'll want to be sure your
Passover side dishes are almost ready to serve when you start cooking the salmon.
Lemon-Roasted AsparagusSpring asparagus is so flavorful that it doesn't require a lot of seasoning to taste great. Toss it with a little grated lemon zest, garlic, salt and pepper, and this vegetable side dish will pair perfectly with any main you choose to serve at Passover Seder.
Chocolate-Dipped Hazelnut MacaroonsSome Seder-goers insist that
coconut macaroons are the only way to finish the meal, but this chocolate-dipped version is so elegant. The chocolate takes about an hour in the refrigerator to set, so make these early in the day and they'll have enough time to cool.
LARYSA LYUNDOVSKA/GETTY IMAGES
Maror (or bitter herbs) symbolizes the Jewish peoples' suffering from being enslaved, and it's an essential part of the
Seder plate. The specific bitter vegetable depends on family traditions, but the most commonly used vegetable is
horseradish. For a bright pink version, try making maror with beets.
Go to Recipe
Sheet-Pan Chicken and VegetablesIf you're running short on time, make the main dish and vegetable sides on a single sheet pan. You can use bone-in thighs, chicken quarters, bone-in breasts or a whole cut-up chicken to make this dish. We recommend using chicken on the bone, though, as it turns out juicier than boneless, skinless cuts.
CharosetThis fruit-and-nut blend, which has a spot on the Seder plate, livens up a piece of matzo, though the specific ingredients in charoset varies on
Passover tables around the world. This recipe is made with a chunky blend of apples and walnuts that simmer in wine and cinnamon to create a homey, warming bite.
Potato KugelNoodle kugel isn't a fit for Passover because the noodles are
chametz, but potato kugel is a perfect addition to the holiday table. This potato kugel recipe uses Russet potatoes, which become soft inside but crisp up to perfection on the top layer.
Chocolate-Covered MatzoIf you've never had chocolate-covered matzo, you're about to fall in love. It tastes similar to chocolate-covered pretzels, with a sweet-and-salty vibe and a perfectly crisp bite. We recommend using unsalted matzo in this recipe, which allows you to control the exact amount of salt.
Matzo BreiThis eggy dish is traditionally served for Passover breakfast or brunch. You can make the matzo brei sweet or savory: For a sweet dish, add cinnamon and sugar to the egg mixture and serve it with applesauce or jam. For a more savory spin, add onions, garlic and peppers to the egg and top the matzo brei with green onions and sour cream.
Passover MeatballsSkip the breadcrumbs and use matzo meal to create Passover-friendly meatballs. Be sure to purchase kosher ground beef if you're making a kosher meal.
Onion KugelPotatoes aren't the only noodle-free version of kugel! This recipe is similar to a
souffle, where the eggs are separated and the whites are beaten until stiff peaks form. That causes the kugel to puff up as it bakes, so the dish looks impressive and tastes light and airy.
Easy Deviled EggsA roasted, boiled egg is one of the symbolic foods that's usually included on the Seder plate, so you may as well boil some extra eggs for eating while you're at it. If you're avoiding
kitniyot for Passover, you'll want to omit the mustard from this recipe.
Cranberry Lime MacaroonsThis sweet treat is the perfect Passover recipe to end a fantastic meal. The macaroons are chewy and light, and the cranberries add color and sweet flavor. Once cooled, you can freeze these macaroons in an airtight container for later. Just let them come to room temp on the counter before serving.
JAMIE THROWER FOR TASTE OF HOME
Unlike Ashkenazi charset made with apples, walnuts and wine, Sephardic charoset is made with dates, raisins and apricots. It resembles more of a paste than a jam, and it tastes delicious when spread on a piece of matzo.
Go to Recipe
Updated: Jan. 21, 2023
